Vintage Bees and 50's Wiring Tone Test/Comparison

nfpa

Junior Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2014
Messages
29
Reaction score
5
can anybody tell what type capacitor this is by looking at the pic?
 

Attachments

muz59

Junior Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2008
Messages
22
Reaction score
7
.047mf bumble bee installed in my 2008 standard. It took 25 minutes all up, the board comes out in one piece, no soldering required to take this out. Replaced stock cap to take the brightness off the bridge HB. Quick and easy upgrade, and neat too.
Can someone tell me how to upload pic??!!
 

jonesy

GLOBAL WIRING GURU
MLP Vendor
Joined
Mar 28, 2008
Messages
17,260
Reaction score
4,518
Originally Posted by nfpa View Post
can a capacitor be put in backwards?

that's a good question.


anyone?

Some of the older wax caps have a polarity indicated by a black band showing that end to ground (-) or electrolytic caps used in amps with high voltage are marked with + & - signs but most capacitors like the Bees and Vitamin Qs are not directional so they can be soldered in your guitar either way and it doesn't really matter.

jonesy
 

dodger916

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2008
Messages
647
Reaction score
288
I'm one who has been happy with the PIO caps I installed in a couple of my guitars, and then I read something that gave me pause. The current flowing through the cap is going to ground, i.e., it's no longer in the signal chain. If so, CAN the cap really affect tone? And if so, how?

"Any two capacitors, no matter the construction will function exactly the same. Doesn't matter if it's a ceramic disc or pio...if they are both 22 micro farads they will sound identical.
You think electrons care?:thumb:"


That myth has been "BUSTED" :)
 

Leo_Gibson

Senior Member
Joined
Apr 10, 2009
Messages
199
Reaction score
71
Assuming all variables could be controlled 100%, including having a robot play the guitar identically each time, I'm wondering if any of us would actually hear a difference between genuine 50s Bees and some cheapo Russian K40Y-9's in a blind test.

I, for one, have suffered from the audio placebo effect e.g. been mixing a track, activated an EQ and found that track sounded better, only to realize the EQ was bypassed. :thumb:\

Thoughts?
 

Meddled

Senior Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2015
Messages
102
Reaction score
82
Bees are way better to my ears. Stocks are sounding fizzier.

Are you high? Are you suggesting the stock capacitors introduce some sort of clipping? Do you understand the role of capacitors in a passive guitar circuit at all? :shock:
 

MATTM

V.I.P. Member
Joined
May 4, 2008
Messages
9,706
Reaction score
6,661
Are you high? Are you suggesting the stock capacitors introduce some sort of clipping? Do you understand the role of capacitors in a passive guitar circuit at all? :shock:
Different dieletrics, different sound. So no, he's "not high" at all.
 

edguidry

Senior Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2013
Messages
196
Reaction score
47
I'm one who has been happy with the PIO caps I installed in a couple of my guitars, and then I read something that gave me pause. The current flowing through the cap is going to ground, i.e., it's no longer in the signal chain. If so, CAN the cap really affect tone? And if so, how?
Two ways.
First, you're left with what's "left" of the tone after the cap bleeds frequencies to ground.
Second, the cap is part of the circuit. it loads the pickup.
 

dmarcus30

Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2010
Messages
65
Reaction score
14
OK, I liked the bees in the first mixes and this mix is even more appealing. The "modern" set-up sounds shrill, squashed, and ratty, to my ears.
The bees sound much more dimensional like "air" around the notes, and the mids and lows are fully present.
THANK YOU for the taste test and ALSO for actually playing the correct chord voicings for ARN!
 

QReuCk

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2013
Messages
303
Reaction score
120
For those who may be interested in it, David Collins' survey tests results (see link on page before if you want to do the test before hearing about the results have been published:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7Hu52vmxE0&feature=youtu.be
Don't open that link if you intent to do the test blind before.

I can confidently say I was very confident with test 5, Had absolutely no idea with test 1, was wrong in test 2 (yeah, I have been tricked by a solid conductor in lieu of a cap with tone pot on 10), wrong again on test 3 and right (out of pure luck probably?) on test 4.
Main critic for me: the playing appeared a bit inconsistant and that could explain some results, but if a blind player's variations have more impact than the cap material, I know where I won't spend my money at least.

I also recommand the whole guitar electronics video series from same A2Guitars Youtube user.
 

Ed hunter

Senior Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2011
Messages
2,603
Reaction score
817
The bee's clip sounded fuller and ballsier even to my old tone deaf ears:thumb:
was it the way the two clips were uploaded?:dunno:
 

God-z1973

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2016
Messages
14
Reaction score
9
I liked to sound of the 50's wiring with the bumble bees. I am curious if other capacitors with equal capacitance as the bees would alter the tone at all.
 

bentfinger

Junior Member
Joined
Mar 25, 2015
Messages
7
Reaction score
2
That is amazing the difference through my system is clear. I love the bees!! They
have brought warmth to your sound.
 

ashbass

V.I.P. Member
Joined
May 3, 2007
Messages
693
Reaction score
533
If the bees are from the 50s as the OP states, they are probably no longer .022 if they even were in the first place. The warmness that many hear may just be that the bee is a higher value cap now and it is taking more high end/treble out of the signal.

I put a toggle switch on my tone pot for a ceramic disc .022 and an orange drop .022. Back and forth. I was stunned that the ceramic disc sounded better. Much more defined, pushed my amp to breakup earlier, and just sounded on target. The OD seemed placid and choked in comparison. Then I measured them. The OD was .021 and the ceramic was .017. So I wasn't hearing the difference of a better cap, I was hearing the difference of a different value cap. I didn't have any ceramic discs that measured closer to the OD so my testing stopped there. But in my experience, cap value will make a difference before cap composition. It is likely that these vintage bees sound so warm because they are of a higher value (due to drift over 60+ years) as compared to whatever value the stock caps are, which may be like mine and measure well under their stated value.

I bought vintage bees in the early 2000s and then black beauties because those were the same as bees. I didn't have a multimeter to test back then but they all went back on ebay after a while. I ended up with orange drop 225s for years after that. Now I've discovered and adopted the LUXE repro bees. If you want bees you should be looking at the LUXE repros. They gots the looks and they gots the guts, and they gots the values that we expect from a vintage bee but mostly no longer get.

I'd like to see the uf measurements for the caps used in the experiment. Are they in pages 2-5 of this thread already?
 




Top