I feel the need to put my 2 cents in , since I'm a bit of a Pickup Pig myself
It really depends on when the Pat.#'s pups were made , doesn't it ? . With Early Pat.#s (first offering) there is almost no difference between the Late PAF's and The Early Pat.#'s . Less the sticker. So why pay more (double) for the sticker?
The middle years of Early Pat.#'s are still close (in tone) to PAF's, but a little different . I happen to like them more than PAF's . The sound is more focused , Imo . And yes, i've tested both back to back, same guitar. The last offerings of Early Pat.#'s were a different animal . I really doubt anyone could
tel the difference between the 2 , listening to them being played at a live setting (Band,club, concert etc.)
Imo, The relative prices for the different pups make them worth considering compared to the cost Of PAF's . PAF prices are nuts Imo.
A late 60's- early 70's Pat.# doesn't cost the same as a 61 Early Pat. # either . Not even close .
Shaws , 15 years ~ later (1980 -'87? ) . Nice pups but not PAF's . Yup, I have a set of them too. They don't sell for much money now.
I think it would be nice if the OP told us what the pickups in the picture are .

alot of conclutions with very little Info.