Kluson tuners replacement for 2014 Traditional

[Deek]

I love love love my 2014 Les Paul Traditional, but the tuners are driving me nuts. The guitar does not stay in tune, is some times sharp after sitting a while and I have eight other guitars right next to it that do not have these issues. I want to replace the "Tonepros Vintage-Style Tunder" it came with. Probably Gotoh as I put a set of those on a jazz box and loved the difference. However, they don't make it easy with clear information. Which ones can I get that do NOT require any reaming or modifications AND have the same look? Thank you in advance - I did search the forum.

 

[hamerfan]

90% of all tuner problems are nut problems. Just saying.

 

[Deek]

I have lightly filed the nut and used some graphite as well. Didn't seem to make any difference at all. I'm not a pro tech by any means, but what is the best way to rule in our out the nut as the problem? GrunGie, I have locking tuners on a Tele and they are amazing in every way. I do want to keep my LP traditional.... traditional though.

 

[Leee]

One quick way to see if the nut is grabbing the strings.
Tune the guitar.
Push down on a string between the tuner and the nut to pull it sharp slightly, and then release.
Then pick the string to check for tuning.
If it remains sharp, that tells you that the nut is grabbing the string and not allowing it to travel in the slot.

I agree on locking tuners.
Everything I own with Rotomatics (the 102) has been swapped out to the locking Rotomatic 502.
Same with all of my Fenders, the locking Schaller is a drop-in swap.

It will not cure the problems of an improperly cut nut, but it makes guitar maintenance quicker and easier.
The string swap takes a fraction of the time, and there’s no more slippage on the post.

 

[Leee]

I was just going to say, I understand that there is a Kluson-style tuner that locks now.
But until I got on the inter-webz and actually found them, I wasn’t going to say anything.

This would’ve saved me from drilling the headstocks on half a dozen Gibsons…

 

[hamerfan]

What Leee said. It's the way how to file a nut correctly. It should not bind, but not sit too loose. It should break only at one spot, but this spot should not be too small.
But if you want to spend money, go for it.

 

[Rocco Crocco]

Guitars go sharp because of reduction on temperature... at least that was always my understanding. Even if that is not right, I can't see how going sharp would have anything to do with the tuners.

 

[diogoguitar]

When I did an overhaul on my LP, my tech put Gotoh Klusson style on her. Hard to beat their Japanese precision.
It stays in tune pretty well and the play is really smooth. It is about 40g lighter if you care about this.

Also, I don't think any permanent mods were done (same hole size, same screw locations)

edit: One more thing, something that helped me get better stability was to always tune up the guitar, never down. If the string is slightly sharp, I'd loosen the string and literally pull the string a bit to go slightly flat, then tune up to pitch. Works really well after the nut is well cut

 

[Skit]

I don't get all these tuner problem people seem to be having. I have been playing for over 50 years and had a lot of guitars. I have never had a problem with tuners.

 

[Deek]

One quick way to see if the nut is grabbing the strings.
Tune the guitar.
Push down on a string between the tuner and the nut to pull it sharp slightly, and then release.
Then pick the string to check for tuning.
If it remains sharp, that tells you that the nut is grabbing the string and not allowing it to travel in the slot.

I agree on locking tuners.
Everything I own with Rotomatics (the 102) has been swapped out to the locking Rotomatic 502.
Same with all of my Fenders, the locking Schaller is a drop-in swap.

It will not cure the problems of an improperly cut nut, but it makes guitar maintenance quicker and easier.
The string swap takes a fraction of the time, and there’s no more slippage on the post.

Thank you for a useful and informative response.

 

[gball]

I replace most of mine with Kluson Revolutions. But not for tuning problems - for those I agree its all about the nut/setup. I use the revolutions because they have a higher ratio and add some mass to the headstock. The stock Kluson Deluxe are fine tuners but only a 14:1 ratio.

 

[Leee]

Guitars go sharp because of reduction on temperature...

Yes.
Metals expand and contract more than most people realize.
And more than wood, apparently, in a linear fashion.
I can think of several instances over the years where I picked up a guitar that has sat untouched for a few months and every string was surprisingly sharp.
Only difference was cooler weather and the house remaining cooler than in an Arizona or Texas summer with air-conditioning cycling on and off.

 

[PAPADON]

Grovers

 

[mvenuti1980]

Guitars go sharp because of reduction on temperature... at least that was always my understanding. Even if that is not right, I can't see how going sharp would have anything to do with the tuners.

All of my guitars have either locking tuners or a locking nut. The room I keep them in has poor insulation so it gets colder at night. Without fail, my guitars are a semi tone sharp every time I pickup them up in the fall and winter.

 

[musicmaniac]

I've got a set of Kluson Revolutions too and love them!

 

[hamerfan]

Then you really need to buy a guitar tuner...
Sorry but I cannot believe that after 50 years of playing you NEVER had tuning issues or not even one guitar with crappy tuners.

I didn´t have either. I recently bought a used set of klusons and put it on my partscaster. Some cleaning and lubing, some retightening of the tabs. And they work.

 

[Deek]

One quick way to see if the nut is grabbing the strings.
Tune the guitar.
Push down on a string between the tuner and the nut to pull it sharp slightly, and then release.
Then pick the string to check for tuning.
If it remains sharp, that tells you that the nut is grabbing the string and not allowing it to travel in the slot.

Okay, doing this test no change. Meanwhile all strings, but in particular the top 3 strings, go out of tune very easily with just a little bending or even playing without much bending and I have stretched the living hell out of the strings AND this happens with different strings over the past year. I have eight guitars. I know how to string a guitar. This one is the only with these tuning problems. I noticed my Ibanez PM2 became a rock solid in tune guitar after upgrading to Gotoh tuners. So...

I like locking tuners, I don't mind spending the money, so what the heck, I am going to get them. These seem like the ones to get for this guitar. I'm also going to get a new nut as I loved the change after upgrading the nut on my Epiphone Les Paul with a Graph Tech.

 

[uncle mud]

I don't get all these tuner problem people seem to be having. I have been playing for over 50 years and had a lot of guitars. I have never had a problem with tuners.

Same here!

 

[uncle mud]

If you learn how to wrap a string at the tuning peg so it doesn't slip, you can get by just fine without locking tuners, and save a few bucks.

 

[Deek]

If you learn how to wrap a string at the tuning peg so it doesn't slip, you can get by just fine without locking tuners, and save a few bucks.

Jesus how many times do I have to say I have eight guitars, have had 40 over the years, I know how to string them, and of all the ones I have right now in the same room, they all stay in tune, except this one. Oh, and I did the nut trick and it seems to be fine.