Help with pickup selection in EPI

[Inhuman]

HEllo there... I own an epiphone black beauty (3 pups, mahogany, etc) and I am switching out my crappy stock pups. I play indie music comparable to Radiohead, Interpol, The Cure. I don't use too much distortion, mostly the reverb, delay/tremolo style modulation. I have been doing some research and have narrowed it down to the following setups:

seymour duncan 59n/SD Phat cat middle/seymour duncan sh-14 custom 5
or
SD 59n/phat cat/gibson 57 classic plus (bridge)
or
G57 classic neck/phat cat/57 classic plus+ bridge

I am chasing a nice clean warm, fat, vintage tone. The neck I need to minimize the mids...don't need no mud. Bridge want it to complement the neck and be clear when alon and well balanced. Any recommendation please?

 

[MrRhoads]

i would go for the Gibson 57 classics
they were killer in a SG 61 reissue i played.

 

[Custom53]

HEllo there... I own an epiphone black beauty (3 pups, mahogany, etc) and I am switching out my crappy stock pups. I play indie music comparable to Radiohead, Interpol, The Cure. I don't use too much distortion, mostly the reverb, delay/tremolo style modulation. I have been doing some research and have narrowed it down to the following setups:

seymour duncan 59n/SD Phat cat middle/seymour duncan sh-14 custom 5
or
SD 59n/phat cat/gibson 57 classic plus (bridge)
or
G57 classic neck/phat cat/57 classic plus+ bridge

I am chasing a nice clean warm, fat, vintage tone. The neck I need to minimize the mids...don't need no mud. Bridge want it to complement the neck and be clear when alon and well balanced. Any recommendation please?

See if this site helps any...

Music page of Pickup Shootout 2009 - MP3 music page on SoundClick