Exile on main street VS. Physical graffiti

[hecube]

Which one is it for you?

 

[Username2]

Physical Graffiti by a mile!

 

[SixAngryStrings]

Physical Graffiti by a mile!

Definitely yes. +1

 

[Its Luke]

Physical Graffiti!
-Although I do love Exile as well

 

[Marshall & Moonshine]

Graffiti. Put it against Sticky Fingers and you've got a fight.

 

[Maynar]

Graffiti. Put it against Sticky Fingers and you've got a fight.

Okay, there's that. But gawdam, PG rules.

 

[SWeAT hOg]

Exile, by a mile!

 

[CHUNKYNECK]

PG, is this a trick question.

 

[Groove Toad]

Exile On Main Street.

 

[kevinpaul]

They are both beyond great. I only picked the stones because I was playing their stuff tonight. They are both important parts of my life. Both hold special histories in their own time and place.

 

[FrankieOliver]

I just ran a four minute mile, so...

 

[James Carney]

I would rather take Hot Rocks over Exile, and take LZ first 5s over PG, but PG destroys Exile.

 

[tazzboy]

Exile on Main Street Track List

Tracklist
Rocks Off 4:33
Rip This Joint 2:24
Shake Your Hips 2:58
Casino Boogie 3:30
Tumbling Dice 3:30
Sweet Virginia 4:25
Torn And Frayed 3:40
Sweet Black Angel 3:05
Loving Cup 4:22
Happy 3:00
Turd On The Run 2:33
Ventilator Blues 3:20
I Just Want To See His Face 3:15
Let It Loose 5:17
All Down The Line 3:50
Stop Breaking Down 4:34
Shine A Light 4:15
Soul Survivor 3:50

Physical Graffiti Track List

Tracklist
Custard Pie 4:20
The Rover 5:54
In My Time Of Dying 11:08
Houses Of The Holy 4:01
Trampled Under Foot 5:38
Kashmir 9:41
In The Light 8:46
Bron-Yr-Aur 2:07
Down By The Seaside 5:15
Ten Years Gone 6:55
Night Flight 3:37
The Wanton Song 4:10
Boogie With Stu 3:45
Black Country Woman 4:30
Sick Again 4:40

 

[kevinpaul]

Of the two choices I like Sticky Fingers and Led Zeppelin 2 about the same. Now Led Zeppelin 3 against the Rolling Stones Tattoo You and it's a toss up. I like both bands a lot. Now David Bowie vs T Rex? Bowie only because he wore seat belts.

 

[circles]

since I'm not really a huge stones fan, plus PG as great, it was not hard to decided.

what about main street vs houses of the ho hos?

 

[politenessman]

thats about a tie. but beggars banquet and especially let it bleed blow physical graffiti away. that was the stones absolute peak. those 2 albums were their rubber soul and revolver.

 

[Chilli]

I think the sleeve artwork on PG is better.

 

[niceguyrichy]

Graffiti. Put it against Sticky Fingers and you've got a fight.

^ that
Sticky Fingers is one of the the great rock albums, right up there with PG

 

[EvLectric]

thats about a tie. but beggars banquet and especially let it bleed blow physical graffiti away. that was the stones absolute peak. those 2 albums were their rubber soul and revolver.

7 to 34 is a tie? Is that new math?

 

[WholeLottaIzzy]

Definitely Exile. While I love Zeppelin, Stones will always come first.