Are people really claiming carelessness on this one? Huh? Looks like a well played guitar to me. This guitar is PLAYED, plain and simple, and nicks and dings happen, even when being careful, especially when playing in a band or traveling.
And like someone already said, people are paying big money for "aged from the factory" guitars.
The way I see this one? Looks like the guitar has character and a story to it. As long as the price reflects the condition (and it looks like it does) AND it plays well (usually a guitar does if someone stuck with it long enough to put that much wear on it) then it's good in my book.
When I was a new to playing guitar I only wanted pristine samples... not any more.