As the title says. I bought a Goldtop from Reverb. Seller had 250+ feedback, mostly positive. As I always do, I documented the box as it was when it arrived. Took pictures of the in boxing etc. Thankfully I did this. Guitar arrives in a box that smelled like cat piss. And had visible stains of cat piss. As I opened the box I noticed the seller had packed it with baby diapers, plastic bottles, and a few newspaper clippings. Not impressed. Guitar itself was in a gig bag. The gig bag had a broken zipper and corrosion all down the zipper. It REEEEEEEKED of cat piss and had cat hair all over it. The bag was disgusting. I finally get the guitar out. Honestly I couldn't get the cat pee smell off the guitar. Even after I showered multiple times and removed the packing stuff and bag from my house. It was that bad. So... I emailed the seller via reverb. Sent him pictures of the entire process. I wish I could have sent him smells. He FOUGHT ME and said it was shipped acceptably because the guitar was not visibly damaged during shipment. Long story short after multiple ranting emails from him begging me to keep the guitar, reverb stepped in and made him take the return. Did I ship it back in exactly the same shipping materials he sent me? You bet I did. After all they were acceptable according to him. I learned that reviews and feedback don't mean a whole lot at reverb. I'll just keep buying new when it's heavily discounted, or buy local and hands on. What's your worst experience buying a guitar online?